Also explaining that it wasn't Dean's fault would mean that at that time sam cared about Dean but him t not telling Dean he's alive tells me sam didn't care about Dean all that year.
This is another point I can't really go with. Sam is distant and has weird and misguided reasons for doing what he did, but I don't think that he no longer cares for Dean. We're not getting the whole story, but if it comes out that Sam no longer has any feelings of affection of any sort for Dean, that . . . won't work.
It's ok but seeing things from sam's POV doesn't make it right for me. I can see why he would tell the Campbells but i can't justify it and actually i don't want to.
Of course seeing something from someone's point of view doesn't make it right. If I've given the impression that I approve of what Sam's been doing, I'm not communicating myself clearly. But seeing something from someone else's point of view helps us understand why he does what he does, and though it doesn't justify it, it will hopefully help us learn.
I think the sooner sam will get a wake up call the better.
Well, that, at least, we agree on. Though after tonight's ep, I'm not convinced that there isn't something going on that is maybe hampering or suppressing Sam's Sammy-ness.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
branchandroot
no subject
Date: 2010-10-09 02:09 am (UTC)This is another point I can't really go with. Sam is distant and has weird and misguided reasons for doing what he did, but I don't think that he no longer cares for Dean. We're not getting the whole story, but if it comes out that Sam no longer has any feelings of affection of any sort for Dean, that . . . won't work.
It's ok but seeing things from sam's POV doesn't make it right for me. I can see why he would tell the Campbells but i can't justify it and actually i don't want to.
Of course seeing something from someone's point of view doesn't make it right. If I've given the impression that I approve of what Sam's been doing, I'm not communicating myself clearly. But seeing something from someone else's point of view helps us understand why he does what he does, and though it doesn't justify it, it will hopefully help us learn.
I think the sooner sam will get a wake up call the better.
Well, that, at least, we agree on. Though after tonight's ep, I'm not convinced that there isn't something going on that is maybe hampering or suppressing Sam's Sammy-ness.